This post might better be entitled:
Growing Children Into Adults Through Verbal Interaction
but, that is such a “technical” title when really this concept isn’t technical at all.
I’ve been reading Let Us Highly Resolve
by David & Shirley Quine for a homeschooling Bible/book study I am participating in this year. In Chapter 3, the Quines tackle the subject of helping your child move from childish reasoning to mature, adult reasoning (1 Cor 13:11).
First of all, let me preface what I am about to say with a statistic from the book that surprised me, keeping in mind this book was written in 1996…
Research studies show various trends of movement from childish to adult levels of reasoning…children being taught at home begin to reason abstractly between nine and ten. Children being taught in [public or private institutional settings] seem to make this transition between 15-20 years of age.
My educated guess as to why there is this huge discrepancy between these two educational models is that one is parent-driven and the other is peer-driven. Which brings me to the meat of this post.
In this same chapter, Quine speaks briefly about including your child in adult conversations, rather than isolating them from such interactions. This is a concept I have struggled with off and on before finally arriving upon what I feel is a happy medium.
Now, you all know I am a huge proponent of dialoguing with your child on everything under the sun; however, when it came to my children listening in on adult conversations, I wasn’t so sure I wanted to go there.
Adults often talk of things that children simply cannot grasp. Some of these things can come back to bite you. For instance, my 12 year old son is forever only getting half the conversation right when he listens in. He later repeats something from the conversation totally out of context, making it sound very odd, if not downright harsh.
There are also topics which come up in adult conversations that are not for children’s ears. Because of these two factors I hesitated to let my children sit in on any adult conversations for fear they would either misconstrue what they heard or hear something I wasn’t ready to explain.
After much thought, Ty and I decided to strike a balance…one that both fosters adult reasoning in our children, but allows for private adult conversations to go on without immature ears around.
When we have company or we are company in someone else’s home, we allow our children to sit in on the conversations for a certain amount of time and then we ask that they leave the room. For instance, my 12 year old will often be allowed to listen (occasionally contributing as well) for 30 minutes before we require he leave the room and either find something else to do or entertain the little ones. He continues this back and forth as long as the adults are visiting. This way he gets a healthy dose of adult-ness while allowing the adults a more open conversation without him listening in.
In addition to this, we make sure we immediately tackle any difficult vocabulary he may hear right then and there. Later, we discuss the conversation with him to clarify anything he might be confused on. It doesn’t take long to do this. The end result has been a young man who feels, thinks, and tries to act (with the occassional 12 year old-ness thrown in) like a young MAN, rather than a perpetual child.
I’ve also made it habit to “talk big” to my children. I’ve used big words and then explained those words. I’ve introduced tough concepts without hesitation. If they don’t get all of what I am saying we either go over it until they do or pick it up another day. And most importantly, I’ve tried very hard not to speak “down” to them. This is mostly a tone of voice, rather than the actual words you are speaking. I’ve always spoken to my children in a tone that suggests they are able to speak on an adult level…even when the topic of conversation is nothing more how many cups of sugar the cake needs.
And finally, I ask my children for input. When I rearrange the furniture or rework homeschooling strategies, I ask them to throw out ideas and help me brainstorm solutions. I don’t always use their ideas, but I do genuinely care what they think and they know it. This teaches them to reason on a more adult level because mommy is truly interested in their “adult” ideas. You should see my children step up to the plate when asked their opinion on something! It does a mama’s heart good to see such maturity!
So, there you have our family’s take on encouraging our children to reason on more mature levels through adult conversation. So far, we’ve seen great results and hope to only continue this trend toward raising adults, rather than oversized kids.
To read another article I wrote on this topic, visit At The Well and read my post entitled: Raising Adults.


Kate says
I love teaching kids new things. My daughter picks up on crazy things sometimes! Once (months ago) I was explaining how she liked to sit on the potty but would not use it. Next thing I know she’s naked and on the toilet in the bathroom! She was listening and I didn’t know it (she potty trained soon after this). I truly enjoy teaching her things. She asks me about stuff all the time and I tell her.
My husband swore (before we had kids) that you could reason with them as soon as they were old enough to understand what you were saying. Our parents said we were crazy. But he STILL thinks so. Honestly we’ve stopped tantrums by taking the time to explain. It’s simple: “Those clothes don’t match, choose different ones.” “Your special cup is dirty today, it needs washed.” “You didn’t listen to mommy, which makes mommy and Jesus sad, so you need to go sit in time out.” (That last one is usually met with cries of “Need pray Jesus help!!”) But I LOVE it. And I think all parents should do it. Talk to them, help them understand the world. Thanks. 🙂
Sarah Painter says
i was just dealing with this exact issue last week. i need to find a balance as well.
Sally says
Good post!
Oh, and you look so cute in the picture! 😉
Dusti says
I was just talking to my husband about this. I am amazed how much the kids learn just through conversation. We discuss, books, the news, or even people we know. I hope, hope I’m teaching them to look at the world and people through a Biblical perspective.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts here. We are so blessed to be homeschoolers.
Amy says
Considering I am writing from a homeschooling perspective, I would not expect “institutional” teachers to follow any of my suggestions either. Here are the citations for the studies that comprised that particular quote:
Edmund Marek & David Quine “Reasoning Abilities of Home Educated Children,” Journal of Law, Ethics, and Public Policy, Vol 3 Issue No. 4 1988 pp562-568.
Jean Piaget “Intellectual Evolution from Adolescence to Adulthood.” Human Development 15(1): 1-12,1972.
John Renner and Edmund Marek, The Learning Cycle (Portsmouth, NH Heinemann, 1988), p25.
Angela says
Good post, Amy! I’ve often contemplated the appropriate way to deal with children being (or not being) in the presence of our adult company. I like your input, and while our kids are much younger than your oldest, I like the idea of letting them be with the adults for a period of time and then asking them to go entertain themselves. Thanks for sharing!
Amy says
This is an issue we are thinking a lot about concerning our 7 year old. He often says adult-ish things or speaks in an adult tone of voice, but it comes across as completely inappropriate and annoying. While we are looking forward to the (hopefully) earlier maturing than public school peers, we are having a hard time striking a balance. For right now we’d rather see his speech 7 going on 9 instead of 7 going on 17!
William says
Interesting post,
There definitely should be a balance and discernment will be needed regarding discussing adult issues with your children and the number one way that the adult dialogue is introduced is through Bible study/Devotional time. The word of GOD deals with adult issues all the time and always genders questions.
The more positive dialogue you have with your children the better and as a man that is not always easy for us, but thank GOD for the Spirit that has given us a new and better way of being!
Amy says
Very true! The Bible does tackle tough subjects and discernment must always be employed no matter the topic. Thanks for joining in the conversation!